Australia For the award of a PhD degree, the evaluation is done, by and large, through the medium of written reports on the thesis by two external examiners besides the supervisor. The fate of a thesis hinges on the recommendations of the three examiners assessing the thesis. Written Reports of examiners who have evaluated Ph.
External Examiner Recommends Major Revisions to the Dissertation In cases where the External Examiner recommends major revisions to the dissertation before proceeding to the Oral Defence, Candidates are normally granted exactly one opportunity for major revision and re-examination. External review of the revised dissertation normally involves both the original External Examiner and a new additional External Examiner who is not informed of the previous external exam.
The Research Supervisor and Candidate will be notified by email as early as possible if the External Examiner recommends major revisions to the dissertation and if the Dean or Associate Dean of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies requires that the Candidate address the report and make revisions to the dissertation before proceeding to the Final Oral Defence.
Once the revised dissertation has been approved by the Supervisory Committee, the Candidate will be required to submit the dissertation and associated approval memos as outlined under Submitting for Examination. Candidates and Research Supervisors are asked to notify the Doctoral Exams office well in advance of the anticipated submission date so appropriate arrangements can be made with the External Examiners.
If at least one of these two External Examiners recommends that the examination should proceed, then the Final Oral Defence will take place.examiner report is the culmination of many years of supervised research. In Australia and New Zealand, for example, external evaluation of a written thesis is essential if candidates are to be.
When the thesis is sent for examination, the examiner(s) have a minimum of four (4) weeks to evaluate the thesis and return the thesis examination report(s). When the completed examiners’reports have been returned to GPS, the procedures for Master’s theses and Doctoral theses are as follows.
Keynote address: Sid Bourke, University of Newcastle. Australia 1 Stellenbosch University, South Africa Abstract As there is no PhD curriculum as such, it is the thesis examiners who set the standard of The most direct source of such information is the content of the written examiner report.
64 thoughts on “ 4 things you should know about choosing examiners for your thesis ” Lynne I didn’t at all relish receiving an examiner’s report saying ‘opening of thesis reads like a tabloid headline’ and other worse comments – I think it’s important to find someone .
EXTERNAL EXAMINER'S REPORT Name of the thesis candidate: Faculty: Stella lacovides University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg,South Africa General notices: the current format of the thesis whereby the study .
EXTERNAL EXAMINER'S REPORT Name of the thesis candidate: Faculty: Stella lacovides University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg,South Africa General notices: the current format of the thesis whereby the study in Chapter 2b directly follows that of Chapter 2a.